Equanimity

Local sustainability

A Viable Rival Currency

People often say of complimentary community currencies like LETS (Local Exchange Trading System) “I don’t know why it hasn’t taken off – it’s such a good idea!”

In this opinion piece, I look at what’s holding LETS back, and suggest a solution.

We can buy almost anything with the Aussie dollar, so why do we bother with LETS? Some reasons are:

  • It is fair money that is not a pump for the wealthy
  • It associates us with like-minded people, who support a spirit of generosity and waste reduction
  • You don’t need dollars to trade; you don’t need to buy ‘Units’ and there is no currency converting

However, the purchasing power and ease of use of a currency is crucial to its success.

What is ‘success’?

Bitcoin has attracted a great deal of attention and appeal because it’s become a valuable investment commodity. One Bitcoin is worth thousands of dollars. People want it, even though its purchasing power (what it can be spent on) is limited because it can be speculated on and converted to dollars. It’s very easy to use because it’s a crypto-currency and criminals like it because it by-passes banks and a lot of government regulations. Primarily, it is a tool for wealth accumulation. It certainly fails to change the culture of greed.

LETS on CES (Community Exchange System) is not convertible to dollars and that is a feather in its cap; it is mutual credit. This sets it apart and is its draw-card. What makes it intrinsically more valuable than the debt-based currency of the mega-rich is that it cultivates the wealth and well-being of the community.

However, it is hampered by the lack of goods and services on offer and its difficulty of use.

Technology

For years, LETS exchange groups have struggled to overcome these barriers. One technologically promising light on the hill is mutual credit as crypto-currency on the Holochain. However, this is still in its infancy. They would almost certainly go much further in solving the ease-of-use problems that CES has made a start on. Some of you may be interested in philanthropically supporting these endeavours by members of the open-source community.

CES in Australia has super-powered what LETS was doing on paper, but it is far from perfect. It requires time and training.

Values

Mutual credit also requires time and training for users to grasp the basic values that are so different to the dollar system. However, people are drawn to it because they are open to its values. It just requires an adjustment period. It also takes some time for some people to develop trust and confidence in the system, in order to bring something of real worth to it. When they are ready, they can add value to the mutual credit economy by;

  • trading entirely in mutual credit when you would otherwise have traded in dollars (big ticket items such as flat-screen TVs, cars, property and houses, specialist services, etc. bring a great deal of value to the currency),
  • donating goods, services, skills or dollars to the organisation and community,
  • valuing the opportunity; in other words take the time to learn how to trade on the systems available. Think of it as “building the alternative”.

A critical element in the adjustment for most people is to offer services and goods of real value. Not just excess food, second hand goods and basic services, but boutique products, near-new cars, electronics, property and expert services. This requires a spirit of philanthropic generosity, especially by the dollar-rich. Without this, LETS will remain a recycling market on the fringes of people’s economy. By investing in LETS, the payout is a healthier, happier, safer and more vibrant community to live in.

Good Growth

Many local currency systems like LETS are appealing for social reasons. It associates us with like-minded people, who support a spirit of generosity. Whilst this may have the feel-good factor of a congregation, it can hold the system down in size and value. The key to mutual credit going beyond a small social circle is to introduce an element of competitiveness with the dollar.

While LETS/CES remains a small social circle, it will continue to eat itself up. This is only natural. When people come together to help each other, it’s healthy to allow transactionalism to dissolve into trust. We become friends and no longer need to ‘keep a track of favours’. We no longer need to use CES. The love grows. Therefore, it’s greatest virtue is its undoing, in a sense.

Shift Happens

However, the way out of this conundrum is to compete with the dollar market; draw in newcomers and expand the mutual credit economy. This in turn will expand the gifting within the association of mutual credit users. Success is an ever-expanding society of giving, sharing and trust that gobbles up value from the dollar economy.

Administration and management

Running a mutual credit system is a complex business and this brings us to the third and final impediment to LETS’ success.

As long as exchanges are run by well-intentioned novices offering their time as volunteers with a hobby-like interest, making decisions on a consensus basis, the complexity of the issues involved will always prevent them from being able to offer a system that has real appeal and reasonably easy uptake. The concepts I’ve described above are not the only challenges. Monetary systems become very complex very quickly as soon as one turns attention to the details of where the money comes from and how it should circulate. One way or another, they have to bite the bullet and put their faith in a dedicated team of specialists or experts, if they are lucky enough to have such people available. Most likely a well-informed management team will need to introduce changes and draw members along with them. This may involve a period of tension as new limitations are introduced, such as suspending or closing inactive accounts, to ensure the viability of the system.

Transparency is essential and this team should always be ready to educate and share their knowledge and skills. In fact this is essential, because it provides a path for ordinary users to become part of the team and raises the general skill level of users. Like the inner workings of a computer, the mechanics is only obscured by its complexity. The results of the teams’ efforts – a more successful mutual credit economy – will be enjoyed by all who use it to trade, just as those who enjoy using computers and cars do without any idea of what’s going on under the bonnet. This success is the basis of the trust placed in the experts and specialists by users.

This team should be properly paid in mutual credits to support their time and livelihood on a regular basis.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on May 14, 2022 by .
%d bloggers like this: